Heaven and Earth: Global Warming — The Missing Science is a popular science book published in 2009 and written by Australian geologist and mining company director Ian Plimer. It argues against the scientific consensus on climate change, rejecting the view that global warming is "very likely due to the observed increase in anthropogenic (man-made) greenhouse gas concentrations" and asserting that the debate is being driven by what the author regards as irrational and unscientific elements.
The book received positive reviews from the conservative press who called it "all the scientific ammunition climate change skeptics could want." Other reviewers, including scientists, criticised the book as unscientific, inaccurate, based on obsolete research, and internally inconsistent.
Heaven and Earth was a bestseller among Australian independent bookstores when published in May 2009, and has already gone through five printings there, according to the publisher. The book has also been published in the United States and the United Kingdom.
Background
Heaven and Earth is a sequel to a previous popular science work by Plimer called A Short History of Planet Earth . Published in 2001, A Short History was based on a decade's worth of radio broadcasts by Plimer aimed mainly at rural Australians. It became a bestseller and won a Eureka Prize in 2002. However, Plimer was unable to find any major publisher willing to publish his follow-up book. He attributed this to there being "a lot of fear out there. No one wants to go against the popular paradigm." Plimer turned to Connor Court Publishing, a husband-and-wife operation based in Ballan, Victoria. The company has a history of publishing books on "culture, justice and religion", including many books on Christianity and Catholicism in particular. It has also published fellow Australian climate change skeptic Garth Paltridge's book, The Climate Caper , which likewise criticises the climate change consensus and the "politicisation of science". Crikey magazine commented that the publication of Heaven and Earth was a coup for conservatives, and said of the publisher: "The conservatives have a new friend in publishing".
According to Plimer, he wrote Heaven and Earth after being "incensed by increasing public acceptance of the idea that humans have caused global warming" and set out to "knock out every single argument we hear about climate change." Although he does not dispute that climate change is happening, he argues that "It's got nothing to do with the atmosphere, it's about what happens in the galaxy" and that climate is driven by the sun, the Earth's orbit and plate tectonics rather than the levels of atmospheric greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide. Plimer says his book is for the "average punter in the street" who can "smell something is wrong in the climate debate but can't put a finger on what."
Critics have also regularly questioned Plimer about his commercial interests in the mining industry, but he rejects criticism that the book and his opposition to an emissions trading scheme are the result of these commercial interests.
Synopsis
In the book, Plimer likens the concept of human-induced climate change to creationism and asserts that it is a "fundamentalist religion adopted by urban atheists looking to fill a yawning spiritual gap plaguing the West". Environmental groups are claimed to have filled this gap by having a romantic view of a less developed past. The book is critical of the IPCC, which he claims has allowed "little or no geological, archeological or historical input" in its analyses. If it had, the book asserts, the IPCC would know cold times lead to dwindling populations, social disruption, extinction, disease and catastrophic droughts, while warm times lead to life blossoming and economic booms – suggesting that global warming, were it really caused by humans, should be welcomed.
The book is critical of political efforts to address climate change and argues that extreme environmental changes are inevitable and unavoidable. Meteorologists have a huge amount to gain from climate change research, the book claims, and they have narrowed the climate change debate to the atmosphere, whereas the truth is more complex. Money would be better directed to dealing with problems as they occur rather than making expensive and futile attempts to prevent climate change.
The book differs markedly from the scientific consensus in contending that the Great Barrier Reef will benefit from rising seas, that there is no correlation between carbon dioxide levels and temperature, and that 96% of the greenhouse effect is due to water vapour.
In the book, Plimer asserts that the current theory of human-induced global warming is not in accord with history, archaeology, geology or astronomy and must be rejected, that promotion of this theory as science is fraudulent, and that the current alarm over climate change is the result of bad science. He argues that climate models focus too strongly on the effects of carbon dioxide, rather than factoring in other issues such as solar variation, the effect of clouds, and unreliable temperature measurements.
Reception and criticism
Heaven and Earth received substantial coverage in the Australian and international media. It produced a highly polarised response from reviewers, with members of the conservative press praising the book and many scientists criticising it. A Wall Street Journal columnist called the book "a damning critique" of the theory of man-made global warming, while left-wing journalist and environmental activist George Monbiot listed some of the book's errors with the comment: "Seldom has a book been more cleanly murdered by scientists than Ian Plimer's Heaven and Earth , which purports to show that manmade climate change is nonsense. Since its publication in Australia it has been ridiculed for a hilarious series of schoolboy errors, and its fudging and manipulation of the data."
Reactions from scientists
The book has been widely criticised by scientists and academics. Barry Brook of Adelaide University's Research Institute for Climate Change and Sustainability, who is at the same university as Plimer and has often debated climate change issues with him, described the book as a case study "in how not to be objective" and accused Plimer of using "selective evidence". Brook commented that Plimer's "stated view of climate science is that a vast number of extremely well respected scientists and a whole range of specialist disciplines have fallen prey to delusional self-interest and become nothing more than unthinking ideologues. Plausible to conspiracy theorists, perhaps, but hardly a sane world view, and insulting to all those genuinely committed to real science." He charged that Plimer's assertions about man’s role in climate change were "naive, reflected a poor understanding of climate science, and relied on recycled and distorted arguments that had been repeatedly refuted." Brook also suggested that many of the scientific authors cited by Plimer actually support the consensus view and that their work is misrepresented in Plimer's book. Susannah Eliott, the chief executive of the Australian Science Media Centre, encouraged colleagues to read the book and comment on it, but took the view that "there isn't anything new in there, they are all old arguments".
Many reviewers highlighted factual and sourcing problems in Heaven and Earth . Colin Woodroffe, a coastal geomorphologist at the University of Wollongong, and a lead chapter author for the IPCC AR4, wrote that the book has many errors and will be "remembered for the confrontation it provokes rather than the science it stimulates." Woodroffe noted Plimer's "unbalanced approach to the topic," and concluded that the book was not written as a contribution to any scientific debate, and was evidently not aimed at a scientific audience. Charlie Veron, former chief scientist at the Australian Institute of Marine Science, said every original statement Plimer makes in the book on coral and coral reefs is incorrect, and that Plimer "serve up diagrams from no acknowledged source, diagrams known to be obsolete and diagrams that combine bits of science with bits of fiction."
David Karoly, an atmospheric dynamicist at Melbourne University and a lead author for the IPCC, accused Plimer of misusing data in the book and commented that "it doesn't support the answers with sources." Karoly reviewed the book and concluded: "Given the errors, the non-science, and the nonsense in this book, it should be classified as science fiction in any library that wastes its funds buying it. The book can then be placed on the shelves alongside Michael Crichton's State of Fear , another science fiction book about climate change with many footnotes. The only difference is that there are fewer scientific errors in State of Fear ."
Ian G. Enting, a mathematical physicist at MASCOS, University of Melbourne and author of Twisted, The Distorted Mathematics of Greenhouse Denial , similarly criticised what he described as numerous misrepresentations of the sources cited in the book and charged that Plimer "fails to establish his claim that the human influence on climate can be ignored, relative to natural variation." Enting compiled a list of over 100 errors in the book.
Michael Ashley, an astronomer at the University of New South Wales, criticised the book at length in a review for The Australian in which he characterised the book as "largely a collection of contrarian ideas and conspiracy theories
Heaven and Earth Global Warming... Ian Plimer - $39.95 : Connor Court ...
Ian Plimer - HEAVEN AND EARTH Global Warming: The Missing Science IAN PLIMER ... at The University of Newcastle (1985-1991). His previous book, A Short History of Planet Earth, won ...
Heaven & Earth (1993 film) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Heaven & Earth; Directed by: Oliver Stone: Produced by: Oliver Stone Arnon Milchan ... The film was based on the book When Heaven and Earth Changed Places, which Le Ly Hayslip wrote ...
Amazon.com: Heaven and Earth: Global Warming, the Missing Science ...
This item: Heaven and Earth: Global Warming, the Missing Science by Ian Plimer
Heaven And Earth: Global Warming - The Missing Science: Amazon.co.uk ...
I expected to find arguments in "Heaven and Earth" to support my leanings and I did, but I was also alarmed by the book's weaknesses which have made it easy to dismiss.
HEAVEN AND EARTH<br>In Plimer<br>HARDBACK Heaven and Earth Ian Plimer ...
HEAVEN AND EARTH NO.1. (Independent) - Neilsen Bookscan May 2, 2009 The book has also gone into its fifth ... His previous book, A Short History of Planet Earth, won the Eureka ...
Heaven and Earth (book) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Heaven and Earth: Global Warming — The Missing Science is a popular science book published in 2009 and written by Australian geologist and mining company director Ian Plimer.
Amazon.com: Heaven and Earth : Unseen by the Naked Eye: David Malin ...
... this season that compares to the mind-boggling beauty of "Heaven & Earth" ... This book, though, blew me away. Heaven and Earth presents images we can't see with our naked eyes ...
Move Heaven and Earth Christina Dodd Book Trailer
Sylvan Miles is haunted by dreams of soldiers she could not save. Lord Rand Malkin is recovering from the Napoleonic Wars and his own ghosts.
Quotes Uncovered: Heaven on Earth and Third-World - Freakonomics Blog ...
A while back, I invited readers to submit quotations for which they wanted me to try to trace the origins, using The Yale Book of Quotations and more recent research by me.
Heaven and Earth, Ian Plimer, Book - Barnes & Noble
DELIVERY & GIFT DETAILS: Usually ships within 24 hours. Delivery Time and Shipping Rates. Eligible for gift wrap & gift message.